This election could be the Baby Boomers’ swan song

Fri, Nov 9, 2012


Eighteen years ago, as I sat on the City Council dais with eight other petty elected officials, one of the City Hall regulars came forward to speak on whatever issue was before us at the time. We were used to him, and to the dozen or so aging know-it-alls who had nothing better to do than harangue us.

But that didn’t mean we liked it. That particular afternoon, a female colleague turned to me, rolled her eyes, and whispered softly.

“Old white men!” she said. “Don’t you just hate them?”

Couldn’t agree — that would have meant hating myself! But I knew what she meant. There’s a certain smug stupidity that characterizes white men of a certain age. Many of us born after 1930 were too young to fight in the Second World War or Korea and managed to miss Vietnam. We benefited from the great postwar boom, lived comfortable lives, made plenty of money and continue to believe that our good fortune is entirely of our own making.

George W. Bush and Bill Clinton were born in 1946, Mitt Romney in 1947. Had Romney been elected, our generation of entitled Baby Boomers might have held on to the White House for another eight years. With Obama’s reelection, the torch may have been permanently snatched away from the geezers.

In Typhoon, an account of a terrifying storm at sea, Joseph Conrad describes the ship’s captain.

“Captain MacWhirr had sailed over the surface of the oceans as some men go skimming over the years of existence to sink gently into a placid grave, ignorant of life to the last, without ever having been made to see all it may contain of perfidy, of violence, and of terror. There are on sea and land such men thus fortunate — or thus disdained by destiny or by the sea.”

Look at the placid, unlined faces of Mitt Romney now and of George W. Bush prior to assuming the presidency. Both had “skimmed over the years of existence,” untroubled by the chaos and uncertainty that defines so many American lives.

Thanks to social changes, two recent wars and the Great Recession, many younger Americans have had direct experience with hardship and uncertainty, and even with violence and terror. So whom will they choose next to lead them in 2016 and beyond?

Hillary Clinton? Maybe so — but look at all the feisty young Democrats in the House and Senate. How about New York Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, Maryland Rep. Chris Van Hollen, or Colorado Sen. Michael Bennet?

The Republicans aren’t stupid — they know that votes from Latinos and women won the election for Obama. Can they toss the angry white men to the curb, and try to reshape the party to appeal to a broader demographic? To do so, they’ll have to move away from the “Paulsie Twins” (Rep. Paul Ryan and Sen. Rand Paul) and look for leaders with broader demographic appeal.

It’ll be a tough job, if results from Tuesday’s election are any guide.

In El Paso County, the beating heart of the state Republican Party, voters gave Romney 59.6 percent to Obama’s 38 percent. But voters in Denver went for Obama 73.5 to 24.4, while Boulder County gave Obama a 69.6 to 28 margin. Obama also won Larimer County and the Denver suburbs. Only Weld County (Greeley), of the urbanized Front Range counties, joined El Paso in the Romney column.

The electoral map of Colorado is simple — a blue spine down the center, flanked by deep red, sparsely populated counties to the east and west. Colorado Springs is both an outlier and a harbinger on this demographic map.

For Republicans to win statewide, the party needs massive majorities in El Paso County. Just like four years ago when Obama was first elected, 59-38 doesn’t cut it — the margin here should be closer to 75-25.

Those majorities have slowly eroded in recent years, as the county’s population becomes more diverse, and as local Democrats have become better at turning out their voters (not to mention appealing to Independents). A decade ago, Democrats didn’t have a single seat in El Paso County’s state legislative delegation — and now they have three. Hardly any Republicans represent the Denver-Boulder area.

As Colorado Springs moves slowly toward the center, Republicans will rely even more heavily on their base. They’ll win many local elections, but it may be a long time until the Republican flag flies again at the state Capitol.

That flag, by the way, features a bull elephant carrying a cane, with a long white beard.


3 Comments For This Post

  1. Robert DiLallo Says:

    Of course, you are quite wrong about Baby Boomers and how they voted. In fact, Baby Boomers voted right along the national average vis a vis Democrats, and are staying right around their historic highs, though lower than in 2008. They ran roughly 50/50 Dem/Repub. They leaned more Democratic than either the 30 to 49 yr old cadre, and much more Democratic than the 65+ cadre. Baby Boomers have always been a divided crowd politically. Most likely they will stay that way. See

  2. Brent Green Says:

    I am white and male and just a few years younger than Mitt Romney, but I am also a lifelong populist who has tried to help build a more egalitarian community. A significant percentage of my brotherly peers are of a similar mindset. Most of us are not Neanderthals.

    Recall not-of-color males from earlier generations who fostered inclusiveness during even more repressive times: John Kennedy and Lyndon Johnson come to mind. A big hunk of Boomer Caucasian manliness carried placards for women’s rights or served as community organizers in ghettos or directed anti-homophobic movies such as “Philadelphia.” From their privileged C-suite posts atop countless institutions, Boomer men stomped down patriarchy. They’ve been seen hugging in public and showing disarming displays of empathy for the dispossessed, sometimes a few tears.

    In our justifiable fervor over the triumph of outlier groups that this past presidential election signifies, let us not then concoct a new minority, in the pejorative sense of that word, to be despised and dismissed for the accident of being born with testicles and without color, growing older. When it comes to equal rights, most white Boomer guys today “get it.”

    P.S. Barack Obama was born in 1961. The most consistent and common definition of the Boomer generation is those Americans who were born between 1946 and 1964. Obama’s values include Boomer values: multiculturalism, environmentalism, gender equality, racial equality, enthusiasm for technology, self-empowerment, anti-authoritarian tendencies (ahem, John), etc. And those values live large in Colorado Springs, even among Boomer men, many of whom have helped make the city a great — and desirable — place to live.

  3. Kelly Says:

    Welcome to the USSA. Metropolitan America has taken the reins and will likely keep them. Social programs are built for those communities and they now outnumber the rest of us. It is a sad day when the electorate realizes they have the power to take what they think they deserve from whomever they want and to hell with the consequences. It is the day democracy (a democratic republic in this case) knows it is on its death bed and has only to wonder how much longer it has to struggle for its last breath.