Hazlehurst’s Blog
Insight and commentary from John Hazlehurst

Gazette’s FreshInk gets less ink - like most newspapers these days

The Gazette has abandoned its ambitious plans to publish its FreshInk as a four-day per week free tabloid newspaper and instead has relegated it to a once-a-week insert.

FreshInk, launched during April of this year, was the brainchild of Gazette publisher Steve Pope, who reportedly told his staff at the time that FreshInk was intended to both compete with the Colorado Springs Independent for younger readers and to eventually become a zoned publication available throughout the region.

At the time, some speculated that Pope had created FreshInk specifically as an Independent-killer, in revenge for that paper’s revelations concerning his fudged resume when he first joined the Gazette.

But I don’t think that was ever the plan - the Gazette, like many floundering dailies, was struggling with the recession and with a swiftly changing business environment.

The Gazette’s parent, now-bankrupt Freedom Communications, had tried the same strategy with its publication in Mesa, Arizona, the East Valley Tribune. The strategy didn’t work, and Freedom announced plans to close the paper unless a buyer could be found. Apparently, there’s a buyer in the wings, and freedom has deferred plans for shutting the pub down pending the bankruptcy court’s approval of the proposed deal.

When launched, FreshInk was published with racked distribution throughout Manitou, the west side, and downtown Colorado Springs. During July, a zoned edition of the paper began distribution in Fountain.

But, it appeared that few businesses chose to advertise in FreshInk.

The paper had formidable competitors, including the Independent and the West Side Pioneer, Ken Jordan’s feisty neighborhood weekly, which routinely scoops every other news medium in the city.

During the last two months, FreshInkhad shrunk from 16 pages to 12, and most ads were so-called ‘house ads’, for which little or no compensation was received. And two weeks ago, the paper announced that it would henceforth be available three days weekly, rather than four.

In a curiously-worded announcement in the Gazette yesterday morning, FreshInk editor Tim Bergsten announced that “changes are coming to the Gazette’s citizen journalism platform…it’s natural to shy away from change, to assume that it’s going to be bad.”

“Beginning Jan. 6,” Bergsten continued, “FreshInk will print Wednesdays. On Feb. 3 we’ll launch two more neighborhood papers (serving the Powers Boulevard and Briargate areas). All four neighborhood papers will be delivered in the Gazette to home subscribers.”

In retrospect, it’s easy to say that FreshInk was doomed from day one, a bad idea that somehow implanted itself in the mind of a stubborn boss.

Maybe so - but it takes a certain amount of journalistic chutzpah to launch a print pub of any kind in today’s market, and FreshInk was often interesting and readable. Many observers believe that metro dailies are a dying breed, doomed to follow passenger pigeons and passenger trains into extinction - so I applaud the Gazette for at least trying something, rather than passively accepting what fate may bring.

“Stand by,” Liz Cobb, the Gazette’s Vice President of Marketing said, “More changes are coming.”

And change, if inevitable, is not always good.

When ‘The City of New Orleans’ immortalized passenger rail 40 years ago, Colorado Springs had two competing dailies, as did Denver, as did San Francisco, as did Seattle. America’s network of passenger trains had largely disappeared, leaving only a few faded reminders of a glorious past. Trains were made for songwriters - and newspapers are made by writers.

I suspect that dozens of laid-off journalists are banging away at their keyboards as I write this, hoping to write the book that will define and celebrate the end of journalism as we knew and lived it.

Good luck. And I know you’ve given up on fortune - but don’t expect fame either. Here’s the chorus from ‘The City of New Orleans’, which was written not by Arlo Guthrie, not by Willie Nelson…but by Steve Goodman.

“Nighttime on The City of New Orleans,
Changing cars in Memphis, Tennessee.
Half way home, we’ll be there by morning
Through the Mississippi darkness
Rolling down to the sea.
And all the towns and people seem
To fade into a bad dream
And the steel rails still ain’t heard the news.
The conductor sings his song again,
The passengers will please refrain
This train’s got the disappearing railroad blues.”

<-Back to CSBJ.com


Posted by John Hazlehurst on December 23rd, 2009 :: Filed under Uncategorized
Tags :: , ,

FreshInk - day two

A vast improvement! 

Local news highlighted, a great cover photo and an interesting, local and relevant center spread. 

Looks as if the editorial department at The Gazette is starting to take the new pub seriously - one of the photo credits, a shot of John Shroka at his Harbour Hot Dogs stand on Manitou Avenue, was credited to none other than G editor Jeff Thomas! 

When you can pry the Big Dog away from his computer and get him out on the streets with a camera, then you’re making a statement.

And just as an aside: picked up FreshInk this morning at 7:30 at a rack next to a downtown Starbucks.  The Independent publishes on Thursday, but it had yet to arrive. 

Wake up, guys!  You no longer have the streets to yourselves …

<- Back to CSBJ.com


Posted by John Hazlehurst on May 7th, 2009 :: Filed under Blog, Uncategorized
Tags :: , ,

Not so fresh ‘ink’

The newspaper wars kicked off today as The Gazette’s Indy killer, FreshInk, hit the stands. 

The paper was conceived just a few weeks ago, and the folks responsible for putting it together had to work against tight, demanding deadlines.

Originally titled “Ink”, then re-titled “FreeG” (groan!!!) and finally FreshInk, it’s a perfectly acceptable first effort - but it’s so pedestrian, so yawn-inducing, and so … well, such a typical product of hack journalism that, unless it’s improved dramatically, The Independent will have nothing to worry about.

The good: The G’s sales team did its job. Of 20 pages, 12 are devoted to ads - a healthy 60-40 ratio. In addition, many of the ads are from advertisers who, to the best of my knowledge, have seldom  appeared in The Independent, including  Renewal by Anderson, Jan-Pro, Phil Long and Broyhill Furniture. 

There’s a healthy classified section, and good events listings.  One obvious omission: no movie times!

Ads are fine - you can’t publish a free newspaper without them.  But let’s look at design and content, because that’s where the paper stumbles badly.

The front page is - there’s no other way to put this - boring, trite and pedestrian.  There’s nothing fresh, original or eye-grabbing about it. 

Inside, the content is dull at best, with a few stories from the AP wire and a couple of nothingburger “local” stories.  The center photo spread, which should be sprightly, interesting and fun is duller than Grandma’s photo album of her trip to Yellowstone during 1963. 

The pics are arranged just like Grandma’s album, but focused around the the theme of “Children’s Day.”  And when, pray tell, was “Children’s Day?”  Maybe May 2- or maybe Feb. 28, 2006 - the date on one of the file photos The Gazette dumped in to the spread.

Faults notwithstanding, FreshInk could be a “contenda.”  Suggestions:

1. Hire a graphic designer.

2. Hire a couple of young, energetic reporters whose brains haven’t been fried by years of laboring in the Vale of Mordor (aka, a daily newspaper).

3. De-Gazettify the content - make FreshInk a real, stand-alone newspaper with original reporting, lively graphics and a sense of fun. 

But for now, it doesn’t feel fresh at all - more like a tired rerun. 

Think “Fresh Prince of Bel-Air”… wasn’t that a TV show back when Grandma and Grandpa went to Yellowstone?

<- Back to CSBJ.com


Posted by John Hazlehurst on May 6th, 2009 :: Filed under Blog
Tags :: , , ,